Welcome to Old Poland Bakery
Old Poland Bakery in Brooklyn is a hidden gem with a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff. Known for their peach cheesecake, babka, bread, strudels, and poppy seed rolls, this classic old Polish bakery offers high-quality baked goods at great prices. Customers rave about the moist and delectable cakes, with one saying they wish they had bought more slices to bring home. The bakery also offers savory options like apple turnovers and cheese-filled puffs. Despite a $5 card minimum, patrons appreciate the value and taste of the treats at Old Poland Bakery. Drive the extra miles for a taste of perfection.
Old Poland Bakery: Reviews & Ratings
Good bakery. A bit of a hole in the wall but with an attentive staff member. She shared ideas on her favorites and they were all pretty good. We ended up having the peach cheesecake - loved it. We had a certain babka too, which we also enjoyed.
i drive 45 minutes to get here that's all you need to know. It's good stuff. I like the cake and bread amazing quality and the prices are a great. I know there are two girls working there one is really nice the other not so much. She's not mean but you can tell she's just there to do her job and go home lol. Which isn't a problem just surprising to her act that way knowing how the other girl is.
A classic old Polish bakery, with great bread, strudels, and poppy seed rolls
This bakery is absolutely terrific. I have purchased some of the best bread I've ever had from this establishment. I wish I had bought more slices of cake to bring home with me because everything was so moist, delectable, and absolutely mouth-watering.
They have a $5 card minimum but apart from that it's a great bakery and very well priced. The Apple turnover and cheese filled puff were both very good.
I got a huge TGTG order (29 pastries!). I got to try a bunch of things but bottom line is that they are generally less flaky/buttery/sweet than a typical French good. They taste more plain, so probably work better for folks who want less decadent pastries. In reheating them, I found that a longer time at lower heat (15 mins at 250 degrees) worked best. Regular croissants were too bland for my liking, but the chocolate one was more interesting (chocolate was more coagulated in a nice way). Cheese croissant (sweet) was better too. There was a plethora of squarish pastries with a slightly sweet cheese filling and 3-4 raisins. They were topped with a light scattering of crumble. Very filling. Also had poppy seed loaf, a loaf with a side pocket of grape(?) jelly, strudel with the same cheese filling as the squares, and apple strudel.
When I am craving Paczki (aka Polish Donut) this bakery is my go-to place . What makes a good paczki is of course a great recipe, achieved at this bakery . The ones here are filled with delicious jelly , the right amount at that . The paczki is light and airy inside but dense. A win-win-win! This bakery also makes a scrumptious cheese Babka. With al the goodies they sell , you will walk out with many items . The prices are reasonable too with such great quality.
Location
-
926 Manhattan Ave Brooklyn, NY 11222 Hotline:
Nested between the bustling streets of Brooklyn, New York, lies a hidden gem known as Old Poland Bakery. This quaint bakery offers a wide array of delectable treats that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth cravings. With options for delivery, takeout, and the convenience of street and bike parking, Old Poland Bakery makes indulging in their treats a breeze.
Customers rave about the attentiveness of the staff, with one reviewer mentioning how they received recommendations on the bakery's favorites. From peach cheesecake to babka, each item on the menu is crafted with care and attention to detail. The classic Polish bakery specializes in bread, strudels, and poppy seed rolls that transport you to the heart of Eastern Europe with every bite.
One customer even goes as far as to say they drive 45 minutes just to get their hands on the bakery's goodies, a true testament to the quality and taste of Old Poland Bakery's offerings. With affordable prices and a welcoming atmosphere, this bakery is a must-visit for anyone looking to indulge in traditional Polish baked goods.
As a food reviewer, I have personally sampled the delights of Old Poland Bakery and can attest to the mouth-watering flavors and moist textures present in their baked goods. The Apple turnover and cheese-filled puff were standout items that left me craving more. The bakery's commitment to quality and taste shines through in every bite, making it a top contender for the best bakery in Brooklyn.
